Many startups fall into a trap by trying to imitate larger, established companies. While this approach may seem smart, it often backfires, especially when startups hit what’s known as "the chasm"—a critical phase where they can lose momentum and stall out.
The term “the chasm” comes from Geoffrey Moore’s book, Crossing the Chasm, which describes the tricky transition from serving early adopters to attracting a larger, mainstream market. At this point, startups face a choice: do they spread themselves thin trying to serve everyone, or focus on what they do best?
This is where "flexible specialists" and "unstable generalists" come in—terms I first heard discussed on Leah Tharin’s podcast with Anthony Pierri. Leah explains that startups thrive as flexible specialists by offering nimble, tailored solutions that bigger companies can’t match. When startups try to do too much, they become unstable generalists, leading to scattered efforts and a diluted value proposition.
In this post, we’ll explore how startups can avoid this pitfall by embracing the flexible specialist model.
Why Big Companies Are Generalists
Large companies are built for scale and efficiency, serving broad customer segments with streamlined operations. While they offer stability and a wide range of products, they’re less adaptable to small, specialized markets. Focusing on custom solutions for niche markets just isn’t financially practical for them.
Flexible Specialists Attract Pragmatist Customers
Crossing the chasm involves appealing to pragmatic customers who value the stability of larger enterprises but also appreciate solutions that meet their specific needs. Startups can succeed by positioning themselves as flexible specialists that cater to niche markets, which appeals to these risk-averse buyers who prioritize solutions that work.
Here’s how flexible specialists attract pragmatic buyers:
1. Address Specific Pain Points with Whole-Product Solutions
Pragmatists want a complete solution that meets all their needs. By focusing on niche markets, flexible specialists can deeply understand unique pain points and offer comprehensive solutions.
Related Post: The Essential Guide to Why, When, and How to Niche Down
Example: Documentum’s Journey
In 1993, Documentum was struggling with stagnant revenue, hovering around $2 million. When Jeff Miller became CEO, the company faced a choice: compete with larger firms on a broad scale or focus on a critical, underserved market niche. Documentum chose the latter, targeting regulatory affairs departments within pharmaceutical companies.
Pharmaceutical companies at the time were burdened by the slow and costly drug approval process. Each day a drug approval was delayed cost them millions. Documentum recognized this as a high-stakes problem and zeroed in on a solution.
Documentum’s software streamlined the organization and management of regulatory documents, making it easier for pharma companies to compile and submit necessary paperwork. This solution cut down approval times significantly, saving these companies a substantial amount of money. The success within this niche helped Documentum gain the attention of top pharmaceutical executives, who valued the time and cost savings.
By solving such a specialized problem effectively, Documentum bypassed internal resistance, particularly from IT departments that often preferred more established vendors. With this success, Documentum created what’s known as the "bowling pin effect": they expanded into other highly regulated industries, such as chemicals and oil refining, leveraging their strong references and proven track record to grow.
2. Build Trust and Reduce Risk
Pragmatists are cautious, especially with newer companies. Flexible specialists can earn their trust by demonstrating niche expertise and offering personalized support. By focusing resources, they ensure consistent performance, which pragmatists value.
3. Offer Value-Driven Solutions with Competitive Pricing
Flexible specialists can often strike a balance between high-value, customized solutions and competitive pricing by avoiding the overhead costs of serving a broad audience.
Final Thoughts: Play to Your Strengths
Startups should play to their strengths: agility, focus, and deep customer understanding. Rather than competing on the same terms as large companies, they should embrace the flexible specialist model. By focusing on niche markets, providing tailored solutions, and building trust, startups can win over pragmatic buyers, cross the chasm, and position themselves for sustainable growth.
In short: Don’t be a jack-of-all-trades—be a master of your niche.
Subscribe to receive the latest blog posts to your inbox every week.
